Forgot Password?
Home arrow GreeniacsForum
Re:A Move to Mandate the Vaccine (1 viewing)
_GEN_GOTOBOTTOM Post Reply Favoured: 0
TOPIC: Re:A Move to Mandate the Vaccine
#2259
A Move to Mandate the Vaccine 10/09/2012 Karma: 0  
Remember the fearful times when vaccines were linked to negative side effects or autism, sparking a great deal of fear in the minds of parents alike? Probably not, of course, because great deals of us are habituated to the fact that immunization is one of those scientific bulwarks against dilapidating diseases. Sadly there are a select group of people who are fearful of a myth that links autism to measles, mumps and rubella vaccine. It was unfortunate that this fallacious concept was introduced in a British scientific journal, for it has taken over a decade to erase the negative concept of vaccines from the minds of the concerned parent. Apart from this, of course, there are groups who even believe that natural immunization through infection is a healthier alternative to the dastardly vaccine, although essentially there is absolutely no difference in the resulting outcome. In other words, if your child were to survive measles, he/she would likely have memory B lymphocytes and antibodies that constitute immunity to the disease. At the same time, however, why go through a cycle of falling ill and risking death when a vaccination empowers you with the same fundamental biological immune factor? The lack of scientific education in these matters is perhaps a concept that takes most flack for this, or perhaps it is that unnerving tendency to link everything to science that an audience of disbelief begins to emerge. To a person who may not have spent his/her life studying science, it is not unreasonable to assume that he/she will find that science should not be the sole explanation for worldly phenomena. I suppose this is the key misconception, because it doesn’t seem to me that science attempts to explain our origins, but rather seeks to logically make sense of the world of natural phenomena around us.

Recently, California has joined both Washington and Vermont in implementing stricter vaccination controls for individuals. It is now much harder for parents to opt out of vaccinating their children, and any exemption is conditional to them receiving factual information about vaccinations themselves. “Receiving” factual information could subject someone to a very long bureaucratic process that may involve weeks of education before an exemption, and essentially this is main precept behind the law: deterrence. While the law is well intentioned, it makes you wonder whether a more forceful approach will compel individuals to be more scientifically open minded. If anything, couldn’t this further polarize those who are in disbelief?

http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=us-sta
tes-make-opting-out-of-vaccinations-harder
  The administrator has disabled public write access.
#2262
Re:A Move to Mandate the Vaccine 10/10/2012 Karma: 0  
I think this will cause a lot of problems. People are slowly starting to trust science more and more, but taking away anyone's right to decide whether or not to put something into their child's body is pushing it too far. Although I do think that these vaccines are important and would help the overall health of our population, creating laws that forces children to get these vaccines will make the people who were on the fence about whether or not to trust the vaccines angry and fearful of the authority figure. There is no clear way to deal with this situation because every child should be able to take advantage of the advances in science we have, but I don't think I (or other people that fully trust science) will ever be able to understand how the parents who deny these vaccines to their children feel.
  The administrator has disabled public write access.
#2263
Re:A Move to Mandate the Vaccine 10/11/2012 Karma: 1  
I agree. Forcing anyone to do something tends to make them more hateful towards it and more likely to reject it. Vaccines are very helpful, I mean who wants to be sick? I think parents should be strongly encouraged to vaccinate their children but ultimately it is their decision. My parents did it for me and I am grateful but force is never the answer. At the most, strong persuasion is the most extreme it should go.
  The administrator has disabled public write access.
_GEN_GOTOTOP Post Reply
get the latest posts directly to your desktop