Not a member yet? Register Forgot Password?
CFLs vs LEDs Print E-mail
Written by Miranda Huey   
Wednesday, 15 October 2008

CFLs vs LEDs

While a lot of people have heard about the benefits of Compact Fluorescent Light bulbs (CFLs), not as many have heard about or are as familiar with many have heard about Light Emitting Diodes (LEDs). If you are not as familiar with CFLs, or you would just like a quick brush-up, you can read the GreeniacsGuide on CFLs: http://www.greeniacs.com/GreeniacsGuides/Switchs_to_Compact_Fluorescent_Light_Bulb. Just like CFLs, LEDs are great for the environment, great for your wallet, and great for you. Here’s the run-down on LEDs:

BENEFITS for the environment: LEDs are significantly more energy efficient than both incandescent light bulbs and CFLs, which reduces their carbon footprint on the environment. Also, unlike CFLs, LEDs don't have any mercury, so there is no risk of pollution and contamination of water, fish, and food supplies.1

BENEFITS for your wallet: Because LEDs are actually about 20-50 times as efficient as incandescent light bulbs, they can save you many times more money on your electrical bill than CFLs in the long run.2

BENEFITS for you: Many people are wary of using CFLs because of their mercury content, however this is a non-issue with LEDs! CFLs must be disposed of carefully if not recycled, and you can read more about disposal options in the Greeniacs Guide to CFLs (http://www.greeniacs.com/GreeniacsGuides/Switchs_to_Compact_Fluorescent_Light_Bulb). Although CFLs don't usually pose a health hazard, if they happen to break, you might be susceptible to mercury exposure if you are not careful.3

Cost: High

Replacing a simple 25 watt incandescent with an LED bulb can cost around $40.4 However, a recent breakthrough in the production of LEDs may bring down the price of LEDs to the level of CFLs within a couple of years. So for only a few more dollars than incandescent bulbs, LEDs should be coming our way shortly!5

Time and Effort: Low

Switching to LEDs is literally as easy as changing a light bulb. LED arrays can fit into standard light bulb sockets, replacing your incandescent bulb.6 You can find LEDs at your local stores, chain stores such as Target, and online.

How to choose between CFLs and LEDs:

Generally, LEDs are significantly more energy efficient, durable, and long-lasting than CFLs, making them even more friendly for the environment than CFLs. However, there are two major drawbacks. First, they cost significantly more than CFLs. Secondly, the light is much more directional and focused, limiting it as a valid replacement for diffused lighting. Here is a chart-to-chart comparison of their respective characteristics:

Characteristic
CFLs
LEDs
Lifespan
 5 years: The average lifespan for CFLs is about 5 years, which is significantly more than incandescent bulbs, but also significantly less than LEDs. 20 years: The average lifespan for LEDs is about 20 years, significantly longer than both incandescent bulbs and CFLs. This minimizes the amount of light bulbs thrown away, which is good for the environment.
Efficiency
 4X as efficient as incandescent bulbs: CFLs are much more efficient than incandescents, but cannot compare to the extreme energy efficiency of LEDs.7 20-50X as efficient as incandescent bulbs: LEDs are much more energy efficient than both incandescents and CFLs.8 This minimizes the carbon footprint of each light bulb, which is great for curbing global warming.
Total Cost
 Low to Medium: CFLs are relatively low in cost, although usually a little bit more than incandescent bulbs. Many people consider this lower cost more reasonable in the short-run as compared to LEDs. Medium: LEDs are relatively high in cost, but they provide huge savings in the long run on the electricity bill. Because these require significantly fewer replacements, you will also save time and money typically spent replacing light bulbs.9
Mercury
 Yes: CFLs contain mercury filaments in their bulb. If the bulbs break, the exposed mercury can pose a health hazard. You should always make sure to dispose or recycle these bulbs carefully and properly in order to prevent the mercury from entering the environment. No: LEDs don't contain any toxic materials and are relatively safe for you and the environment.10
Durability
 Same as incandescent bulbs: Because CFLs have a mercury filament, it is about as fragile as an incandescent light bulb. For some people, this amount of durability is just fine. Better than incandescent bulb: Because LEDs don't have a filament, they are able to withstand more jarring and bumping than both incandescents and CFLs.11
Light Field
Same as incandescent bulb: CFLs diffuse and radiate light at all angles, making these bulbs ideal for lighting large spaces and rooms. This is a main advantage over LEDs, which focus the light only on one spot. Limited field of light: Most LEDs are focused and directional lights, which means they only focus their beam at one spot. This is ideal for reading lights, task lighting, track light, accent lighting, security lighting, and more.12 However, new designs which diffuse light are coming out on the market as well.13
Uses
 Good replacement for incandescent bulbs: CFLs are great for replacing standard incandescents in your home. Great for other uses: LEDs come in many different colors, which you can use for different purposes. Blue light is great for reducing eyestrain when reading, especially for elderly people. On the other hand, amber light is great for patios and decks, since it doesn't attract insects, unlike white light.14 They also make great holiday lights!

Browse all Greeniacs Guides        Browse all Greeniacs Articles
___________________________________________________________________________________


1http://www.eartheasy.com/live_energyeff_lighting.htm.
2http://www.greentechgazette.com/index.php/energy-conservation/cfl-or-led-light-bulbs/.
3Id.
4http://www.eartheasy.com/live_energyeff_lighting.htm.
5http://www.eartheasy.com/article_led_breakthrough.html.
6http://www.eartheasy.com/live_energyeff_lighting.htm.
7http://www.usatoday.com/tech/news/techinnovations/2005-04-14-led-lighting_x.htm.
8http://www.greentechgazette.com/index.php/energy-conservation/cfl-or-led-light-bulbs/.
9http://www.eartheasy.com/live_energyeff_lighting.htm
10Id.
11Id.
12http://www.kulekat.com/articles/energy/led-home-lighting/led-home-lighting-a-buyers-guide.html.
13http://www.eartheasy.com/live_energyeff_lighting.htm
14Id.


Quote this article on your site

Comments (1)
RSS comments
1. 22-01-2010 18:54
..
Nice post. We didn't realize LEDs are so expensive. How about trying a soy candle instead of expensive lights? haha
Registered

Only registered users can write comments.
Please login or register.

Click here to Register.  Click here to login.
Last Updated ( Monday, 25 January 2010 )

Greeniacs Forum Widget

Add our widget to your favorite websites!
Greeniacs Forum Widget

Polls

Would you lose your lawn and replace it with synthetic grass?

Green Facts

  • If everyone in the U.S. used energy-efficient lighting, we could retire 90 average size power plants

  • Replacing a single incandescent bulb with a CFL will keep a half-ton of CO2 out of the atmosphere over the life of the bulb

  • One-half of our nation's lakes and one-third of our rivers are too polluted to be completely safe for swimming or fishing

  • Turning down your home’s central heating thermostat one degree for an 8-hour period, can cut your fuel consumption by as much as 10% 

  • The average non-agricultural homeowner uses up to 10 times more toxic chemicals per acre than a farmer 

  • There are more roads located within our National Forests than there are within the entire U.S. Interstate Highway system

  • The energy saved from recycling one 8-ounce aluminum can could operate a TV set for 3 hours, which is the equivalent to half a can of gasoline

  • About 80% of what Americans throw away is recyclable, yet our recycling rate is just 28%

  • For every ton of office paper we recycle, 380 gallons of oil are saved