Forgot Password?
Home arrow GreeniacsArticles arrow Energy arrow Future of Natural Gas
Written by William Quinn   
Share |
Monday, 06 June 2011

Future of Natural Gas
Faced with rising oil prices and waning oil reserves around the world, this is the era in which the world’s energy `portfolio will forever change. I view “peak oil ” as occurring the moment that alternative energies become more affordable than continued oil exploration, refinement, and distribution. As long as we are willing to pay more for oil, we will continue to receive oil. But, as soon as we are willing to break our addiction and fully invest in alternative energies, we will forever free ourselves. This change is in the near future. President Obama has spoken out against U.S. dependence on foreign oil, not only because it is a strains our economy, but also for the threats it poses to our national security.1

So, where do we get our power, if not from oil? How do we drive to work, if not with gasoline? What will fuel the everyday operations of the nation? Personally, I do not see enough solar panels, windmills, or nuclear power plants operating around the nation for us to seriously consider them as an exclusive replacement source for our extraordinary energy demands. Coal is touted as a domestic energy source that provides American jobs. “One quarter of the world's coal reserves are found within the United States, and the energy content of the nation's coal resources exceeds that of all the world's known recoverable oil.” 2 Coal also supplies more than half of the electricity consumed by Americans.3 However, I cannot condone industrial scale coal extraction when it leads the massive environmental degradation and permanent scarring of the earth through mountaintop removal .4 Scientific reports have concluded that mountaintop coal mining should cease in the U.S. due to its damage to the environment as well as human health.5 With present nuclear instability, and the slow adoption of alternative energy sources such as wind and solar , what are the nation’s energy options? It may just be natural gas that gets the most votes…

Natural Gas: This colorless, odorless, abundant, and high-energy domestic fuel source is swe eping the nation. Not only can it be used to generate electricity in power plants, but it can even fuel modified vehicles in a compressed or liquid form.6 Since 2001, the percent of natural gas vehicles worldwide has increased by 24 percent.7 In the United States, 900 of the next 1000 power plants will use natural gas! Let’s look at the good, the bad, and the ugly of this emerging energy source…

The Good Side of Natural Gas

Some consider natural gas to be the “cleanest, safest, and most useful of all energy sources.”9 The majority of this combustible mix of hydrocarbon gasses is methane, but it also includes ethane, propane, butane and pentane.10 Like oil, natural gas is formed deep in the earth from pressure on organic matter over millions of years. Unlike oil, natural gas takes intense heat to form, which is why deposits are located deeper in the earth (sometimes 1-2 miles).11 Once the gas is formed, it will rise to the surface due to its low density. Sometimes it makes it all the way to the top, but often, it is absorbed in porous sedimentary rock capped by an impermeable rock layer. Once this formation is drilled, the gas will often release itself due to the pressure difference, making extraction rather simple. However, as technology has improved, we have been receiving an increased supply of natural gas from “unconventional” sources.12 Unconventional sources are simply those that are less economical to extract—examples include deep natural gas (15,000 feet or deeper), tight gas (under great pressure under impenetrable hard rock), and shale gas (very soft sedimentary rock).13

In 2010, natural gas accounted for about 20% of the United States’ electricity generation.14 The cost of producing this electricity from natural gas was less than half than the cost when using petroleum, but around twice as much as when using coal.15 When considering price alone, coal is the clear winner, but when considering emissions and environmental degradation, natural gas appears to be the best option.

Electronic Power Industry Fuel Costs 16


A major MIT report released in 2010 highlighted the fact that natural gas will play a dominant role in greenhouse gas reductions in the U.S. energy sector.17 This is largely due to the fact that new natural gas power plants can replace old inefficient coal fired power plants. With proper implementation and carbon emissions pricing, the U.S. could see a 50% reduction in carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions by 2050.18 Furthermore, natural gas is considered the cleanest of all fossil fuels and its use can reduce the emission of many harmful pollutants. In transportation, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) estimates significant pollutant reductions through the use of natural gas. Benefits of compressed natural gas versus gasoline include reducing carbon monoxide emissions by 90%-97%, carbon dioxide emissions by 25%, and nitrogen oxide emissions by 35%-60%. Another benefit is that natural gas emits fewer toxic and carcinogenic pollutants than petroleum/oil and emits little or no particulate matter.19 These reductions in pollution, greenhouse gases, and particulates are a great reason to increase the role of natural gas in our transportation and energy sectors.

The Bad Side of Natural Gas

Since natural gas is combustible, that inherently means it is explosive. Not only can drilling for natural gas be dangerous—causing deadly explosions even in “routine” maintenance scenarios—but it also poses a threat to citizens and communities.20 In the first week of May 2011 alone, the U.S. saw a dozen natural gas related threats and several explosions.21 In September 2010 there was an enormous natural gas explosion of a PG&E pipeline in San Bruno, California that left eight dead and destroyed 53 homes.22 Some witnesses claimed the fire stretched 300 feet high with the initial explosion going even higher. With reports of leaking natural gas around the nation, people have become increasingly concerned with natural gas explosion risks. A recent Duke study disclosed a surprising level of natural gas leaking into water wells in New York and Pennsylvania from the Marcellus Shale Formation.23 This study further found that “[w]ells within 1 kilometer of gas drilling had 17 times more methane than more distant wells.”24

Concerning human health, the risks of methane consumption through the water supply are unknown as there have been very few investigative studies. Methane is largely considered non-poisonous, but it will displace oxygen if inhaled.25 Some feel that they are being misled by such statements, and claim that methane is toxic and responsible for many of their chronic health issues such as depression, headaches, nausea, and dizziness.26 However, this is largely speculative, and comprehensive studies have not been performed to confirm such claims.

Natural Gas 27


The Ugly Side of Natural Gas

The greatest concern for environmental and human health is method in which natural gas in extracted. As unconventional methods of extraction become economically viable, they are pursued more readily, without full consideration of the consequences. The most rampant example is the extraction of shale gas. Thanks to technological achievements in horizontal drilling and a process known as hydraulic fracking, gas companies can now extract natural gas from shale rock formations. These shale extractions increased by an average annual growth rate of 48% from 2006-2010.28 Furthermore, future projections estimate that shale gas will make up 47% of total natural gas production by 2035.29 So what is the problem with shale gas?

The Future of Natural Gas30


With the percentage of shale gas extraction potentially increasing threefold by 2035, we must critically examine the effects of industry extraction techniques. The practice in question is known as hydraulic fracturing or “fracking.” It involves the high-pressure injection of sand, water, and chemicals into a well. This mixture cracks the shale and fills the cracks with sandy grit. The natural gas then escapes from the shale and travels through the grit, up the well, and to the surface.31

One concern with the “fracking” process is the chemicals that are pumped into the ground, that may end up in the groundwater and public water supplies. From 2005-2009, at least 750 different chemicals were used in the fracking process, many of which are known to cause human health issues in certain quantities.32 The EPA tried to gather what chemicals were being used, but the beauty for corporations is, many of the chemicals are “proprietary” or “trades secret,” so they claimed that could not disclose this information to the public.33 As a result, the EPA issued Halliburton—one of nine major companies that refused to comply—a subpoena for not disclosing their chemicals.34 Only more recently have companies begun to comply, and the public can more readily discover if they are near a well and what chemicals are being used by visiting: fracfocus.org. 35

Another issue is the wastewater left after extraction. It may contain corrosive salts and radioactive/carcinogenic materials.36 The natural gas can also escape into the water supply, the health implications of which are unknown. However, one outcome is known: flammable tap water is not out of the question, a fact highlighted in a recent documentary called GasLand which attempts to shed light on natural gas issues in the U.S.37 The New York Times also created an interactive map which highlights the toxic chemicals found in the wastewater of 149 Pennsylvania wells. This is a great resource to view just how toxic these waste sites can be, with 128 wells containing 1500 times the federal limit on gross alpha radiation.

The Future of Natural Gas38


To add insult to injury, these natural gas extraction methods may actually contribute more to global climate change than coal and petroleum based energies.39 Recent Cornell studies examine the potential for methane gas (one of the most potent greenhouse gases) to escape into the atmosphere during extraction. If this was the case, then all mitigating effects of natural gas against climate change would be lost, and we would be left with just another dirty energy. Unfortunately, this is a booming industry, and energy companies have little incentive to stop and check if they are harming the environment. The Obama administration has created a panel within the Department of Energy to address the concern of hydraulic fracking.40 Hopefully industry standards are revised as a result, or this nation may have another environmental disaster looming in its future.


The Verdict: Natural gas presents an excellent opportunity to reduce our dependence on petroleum and coal based electricity and even transportation fuel. However, if extraction techniques are not forced into environmental compliance, then we could be doing even more damage to human and environmental health.

Browse all Greeniacs Articles Browse all Greeniacs Guides        Browse all Greeniacs Articles
_______________________________________________________________________________

1 http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-502443_162-4253821-502443.html
2 http://www.energy.gov/energysources/coal.htm
3 Id.
4 http://www.ohvec.org/galleries/mountaintop_removal/007/
5 http://www.reuters.com/article/2010/01/07/energy-coal-mountaintop-idUSN0719066720100107
6 http://www.afdc.energy.gov/afdc/vehicles/natural_gas_emissions.html
7 http://www.iangv.org/tools-resources/statistics.html
8 http://www.energy.gov/energysources/naturalgas.htm
9 http://www.naturalgas.org/overview/background.asp
10 Id.
11 Id.
12 http://www.naturalgas.org/overview/unconvent_ng_resource.asp
13 Id.
14 http://www.eia.doe.gov/cneaf/electricity/epm/epm_sum.html
15 Id.
16 Id.
17 http://web.mit.edu/press/2010/natural-gas.html
18 Id.
19 http://www.afdc.energy.gov/afdc/vehicles/natural_gas_emissions.html
20 http://www.ecocentricblog.org/2010/07/27/concerns-over-natural-gas-
drilling-grow-after-deadly-rig-explosion-in-pennsylvania/
21 http://www.naturalgaswatch.org/?p=390
22 http://articles.sfgate.com/2010-09-10/news/23996646_1_gas-line-
explosion-wind-whipped-blaze-smoke-inhalation
23 http://www.sfgate.com/
24 Id.
25 http://www.worsleyschool.net/science/files/methane/page.html
26 http://tobeinformed.com/Dangers-of-Natural-Gas.htm
27 http://www.naturalgaswatch.org/?p=191
28 http://www.eia.doe.gov/forecasts/aeo/chapter_executive_summary.cfm#domestic
29 Id.
30 Id.
31 http://www.usatoday.com/tech/science/environment/
2011-05-09-fracking-environment-water-methane_n.htm
32 http://switchboard.nrdc.org/blogs/amall/new_report_on_hydraulic_fractu.html
33 Id.
34 http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2010/11/09/epa-halliburton-subpoenae_n_781045.html
35 http://www.environmentalleader.com/2011/04/12/24
-companies-agree-to-publish-fracking-chemicals/
36 http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2011/02/27/us/natural-gas-map.html
37 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dZe1AeH0Qz8&feature=related
38 http://www.thechicecologist.com/2010/06/gasland/
39 http://climateprogress.org/2011/04/12/shal-gas-bridge-fuel/
40 http://www.energy.gov/news/10309.htm




Comments (1)
RSS comments
1. 17-11-2011 00:59
Peak Oil
Experts have been warning us for many years regarding converging crises that can end life as we know it. Peak oil, probably has another important message for us. A (http://www.cardealexpert.com/news-information/auto-news/oil-demand-peak-2020/)new study predicts world oil demand will peak in 2020. Moreover, the study cites increased regulation worldwide, improved combustion engine technology and the rise of alternative fuels for the predicted trend.
Registered

Only registered users can write comments.
Please login or register.

Click here to Register.  Click here to login.
Last Updated ( Friday, 21 October 2011 )

SEARCH GREENIACS.COM

Green Facts

  • Bamboo absorbs 35% more carbon dioxide than equivalent stands of trees.

  • One recycled aluminum can will save enough energy to run a 100-watt bulb for 20 hours, a computer for 3 hours, or a TV for 2 hours.

  • You’ll save two pounds of carbon for every 20 glass bottles that you recycle.

  • A single quart of motor oil, if disposed of improperly, can contaminate up to 2,000,000 gallons of fresh water.

  • American workers spend an average of 47 hours per year commuting through rush hour traffic. This adds up to 23 billion gallons of gas wasted in traffic each year.

  • Nudge your thermostat up two degrees in the summer and down two degrees in the winter to prevent 2,000 pounds of carbon dioxide from entering the atmosphere.

  • Recycling for one year at Stanford University saved the equivalent of 33,913 trees and the need for 636 tons of iron ore, coal, and limestone.

  • You will save 100 pounds of carbon for each incandescent bulb that you replace with a compact fluorescent bulb (CFL), over the life of the bulb.

  • In California homes, about 10% of energy usage is related to TVs, DVRs, cable and satellite boxes, and DVD players.

  • States with bottle deposit laws have 35-40% less litter by volume.

  • A tree that provides a home with shade from the sun can reduce the energy required to run the air conditioner and save an additional 200 to 2,000 pounds of carbon over its lifetime.

  • Shaving 10 miles off of your weekly driving pattern can eliminate about 500 pounds of carbon dioxide emissions a year.

  • Americans use 100 million tin and steel cans every day.

  • Refrigerators built in 1975 used 4 times more energy than current models.

  • 82 percent of greenhouse gas emissions in the U.S. come from burning fossil fuels.

  • An aluminum can that is thrown away instead of recycled will still be a can 500 years from now!

  • A steel mill using recycled scrap reduces related water pollution, air pollution, and mining wastes by about 70%.

  • The World Health Organization estimates that 2 million people die prematurely worldwide every year due to air pollution.

  • Every week about 20 species of plants and animals become extinct.

  • Current sea ice levels are at least 47% lower than they were in 1979.

  • In the United States, automobiles produce over 20 percent of total carbon emissions. Walk or bike and you'll save one pound of carbon for every mile you travel.

  • A laptop consumes five times less electricity than a desktop computer.

  • Americans throw away more than 120 million cell phones each year, which contribute 60,000 tons of waste to landfills annually.

  • Turning off the tap when brushing your teeth can save as much as 10 gallons a day per person.

  • If every U.S. household turned the thermostat down by 10 degrees for seven hours each night during the cold months, and seven hours each weekday, it would prevent nearly gas emissions.

  • 77% of people who commute to work by car drive alone.

  • Less than 1% of electricity in the United States is generated from solar power.

  • Rainforests are being cut down at the rate of 100 acres per minute.

  • Recycling 100 million cell phones can save enough energy to power 18,500 homes in the U.S. for a year.

  • Due to tiger poaching, habitat destruction, and other human-tiger conflicts, tigers now number around 3,200—a decrease in population by about 70% from 100 years ago.

  • Plastic bags and other plastic garbage thrown into the ocean kill as many as 1,000,000 sea creatures every year.

  • For every 38,000 bills consumers pay online instead of by mail, 5,058 pounds of greenhouse gases are avoided and two tons of trees are preserved.

  • It takes 6,000,000 trees to make 1 year's worth of tissues for the world.

  • Washing your clothes in cold or warm instead of hot water saves 500 pounds of carbon dioxide a year, and drying your clothes on a clothesline six months out of the year would save another 700 pounds.

  • You will save 300 pounds of carbon dioxide for every 10,000 miles you drive if you always keep your car’s tires fully inflated.

  • Glass can be recycled over and over again without ever wearing down.

  • Recycling aluminum saves 95% of the energy used to make the material from scratch.

  • Americans throw away enough aluminum to rebuild our entire commercial fleet of airplanes every 3 months

  • Recycling 1 million laptop computers can save the amount of energy used by 3,657 homes in the U.S. over the course of a year.